Show Notes
Adam & Dave discuss the week's developments on podcastindex.org with guest Der Gigi
Download the mp3
Podcast Feed
PodcastIndex.org
Preservepodcasting.com
Check out the podcasting 2.0 apps and services newpodcastapps.com
Support us with your Time Talent and Treasure
Positioning
Boost Bait
ShowNotes
Put us in your value split
03ae9f91a0cb8ff43840e3c322c4c61f019d8c1c3cea15a25cfc425ac605e61a4a
š How to add liveItem to your RSS feed - Podfriend
Daniel J Lewis site changes
Boostagrams as comments
Dev meeting
Fdroid store apps
Last Modified 03/18/2022 14:04:09 by Freedom Controller
Activity
@merryoscar
25,000 sats
Mar 19 2022
Sad that Adam doesnāt like our Lightning Comments idea. All we are trying to do here is double down on what is already working and what our users love about Podcasting 2.0. Before this update to show boosts as comments, many of the top podcasters on Fountain were not even able to read the boost messages. In our view this is one of the biggest factors limiting the adoption of value for value. We believe surfacing boosts as comments makes the experience much better for all.
@merryoscar
10,000 sats
Mar 19 2022
On the philosophical debate around whether a comment should cost money to post - surely each app and podcaster can decide which approach they want to take? - if paid comments are just one option in the social interact tag this choice is always available.
On the limits of TLV - we are very aware of this and I donāt think having messages here is the long term solution - but itās working right now for the value block and if itās working there it can work for comments until there's a better option.
@merryoscar
10,000 sats
Mar 19 2022
We are open to using a different cross-app comments system - but I do think integrating boosts is such a cool feature that I know both users and podcasters want.
I havenāt heard any other proposed solutions / suggestions that integrate boosts with comments.
I would love to hear what your preferred approach would be - do you think boosts and comments are fundamentally different and should not be displayed together in apps?
@adam
1,234 sats
Mar 20 2022
so the comnents from my social interact as specified in the feed dont surface in fountain? Or am i seeing both?
@merryoscar
1,000 sats
Mar 21 2022
@adam youāre right we should be showing comments from the social interact tag here. I think we might have taken the running with scissors ethos a bit too far š
although for what itās worth there was a beta version of this available for 2 weeks and we only received good feedback!
@merryoscar
1,000 sats
Mar 24 2022
@dave @adam new version of Fountain is now live that lets us disable lightning comments for shows that don't want them.
I've disabled on Podcasting 2.0.
@adam let me know if you want me to disable for No Agenda / your other shows.
It's manual right now because I didn't see the socialInteract tag in the index API (assuming because the tag is still in proposal)
We will respect it for all shows once it's there, along with a `visibility` attribute or similar if we can add to the value block.
@meremortalspodcast
500 sats
Mar 20 2022
I think it's a great idea Oscar but should be kept separate from 'boostagrams'. For example I just read below every comment they will read on the next show, this makes me less inclined to listen to that section. I think boostagrams should be sent directly to the podcaster and lightning comments to everyone. Maybe just a default 5 or 10 sats for a lightning comment and then boostagrams are where the viewer can send the real 'look at this!' value.
@bmasi
500 sats
Mar 21 2022
@meremortalspodcast - Agreed! Boostagrams and comments should be separate, at very least presented differently because the context of a message to the show and a comment are very different. Iām also not clear, is this a cross-app commenting system or something just in Fountain?
@johnsbrt
24,900 sats
Mar 19 2022
Balance comment
@bmasi
5,000 sats
Mar 20 2022
Donāt just stand thereā¦boost for BTC conversation with Gigi! š§š
@bmasi
6 sats
Mar 20 2022
I see, Fountain now surfaces boosts as comments. Are these actually cross app with the spec or just something Fountain is doing with the boosts it can see (that originate with the app)?
@bmasi
11 sats
Mar 20 2022
Testing a boost comment via the comments screen with āprivateā boosts turned on
@merryoscar
100 sats
Mar 21 2022
@bmasi here you have replied to a comment which inherently cannot be private. Private boosts only affects boosts. I agree this is confusing though - lots of work need to clarify things - apologies to Dave and Adam!
@bmasi
100 sats
Mar 21 2022
Hi @merryoscar, thatās what I was thinking when I tried it. I just wanted to check that I could use comments as comments while boosts were set to private. that way, I can boost to a show directly without it showing as a comment and comment when I want to comment!
@chadf
3,333 sats
Mar 18 2022
Iāve never rolled dice in the bathroom but I have in the living room alone with the curtains closed. You never know who could be watching. š
@meremortalspodcast
6 sats
Mar 18 2022
I'm more of an open air dicer if you know what I mean. I feel like the shape and form of the dice are a natural thing and shouldn't be hidden away. I'm actually thinking of joining a nudist/dice colony. Freeing myself from the shackles of societal stigma š¤£
@kaas peeland
3,300 sats
Mar 20 2022
nice show, Thanks
@nomadjoe
2,000 sats
Mar 19 2022
greetings from the road š£ļø
@merryoscar
1,000 sats
Mar 24 2022
For what itās worth I still believe that having boots public and allowing other listeners and the host to reply in the app brings so much more to the podcast listening experience.
I get that we moved a bit too quickly on this but I would love to come on the show again one day to discuss the pros and cons.
@sirbill
1,000 sats
Mar 19 2022
I confirm I am not Dreb Scott. Boost!
@lintable
500 sats
Mar 22 2022
the new comments are slick. but I feel like boosts and comments should be separate in the future
@chadf
333 sats
Mar 18 2022
Yay! Gigi
@jessypuga
51 sats
Aug 5 2022
...
@meremortalspodcast
50 sats
Mar 18 2022
Wunderschƶn, derrrrrrr Gigi!
@cristobal_mena
20 sats
Jul 28 2022
...
@ignaciobtato
10 sats
Aug 22 2022
...
@ignaciobtato
10 sats
Aug 8 2022
...
@user6327108691808582
10 Oct
good
@coca
5 sats
Jul 25 2022
Gracias dinero
@fabi_araujo
5 sats
Jul 22 2022
HI..!!